Ashtone Morgan gave Toronto the lead with his first MLS goal, but Sebastian Giovinco was then substituted with an injury and David Villa equalized on the stroke of half-time.
After TFC had seen a goal controversially disallowed, Maxi Moralez put New York City in front before Jordan Hamilton won the late penalty for Vazquez to convert.
What did you make of Toronto’s players on the night? Upvote the performances you liked, downvote those you didn’t and skip over any you didn’t feel strongly about. We’ll announce a man of the match based on your votes on Friday.